|
[left.htm]
| |
Seven killers were executed
in February 2003. They had murdered at least
8 people.
Three
killers were given a stay in February 2003.
They have murdered at least 3 people.
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
February 4, 2003 |
Texas |
Joyce
Munguia, 18
unnamed victim |
John Elliott |
executed |
|
John
Elliott was sentenced to death for raping a woman in Austin and then beating her
to death with a motorcycle chain on June 13, 1986. Police said after Joyce
Munguia
was gang-raped by Elliott and two accomplices, she was hit 16 times on the
head and 8 times on the face with a chrome-plated chain under a freeway
overpass. Elliott had previously been in prison in 1982 for "intentional
murder" for which he served only four months of an eight-year sentence. He
also was convicted in 1984 on an attempted burglary charge and was given 10
years probation. Joyce Munguia was 18 years old, the mother of a
one-year-old toddler. In the early evening of June 13, she was at a bus stop
when some men she knew from the neighborhood called to her. John Elliott,
Ricky Elizondo and Robert Hanson were hanging out in the driveway, drinking
beer. Joyce joined the men. Over the next
few hours they shared beer, liquor and cocaine, and
she subsequently had sex with one of them. According
to a witness, she later began crying, was disoriented and asked for help to walk
home. Elliott followed her, then carried her under a
railroad bridge where he and 2 other men raped her,
according to testimony. When she announced she was going to the police, Elliott
beat her with his belt made from a chain, one of the men there testified.
His shoe prints were at the murder scene.
By the time of Joyce's death three hours after she first joined the men, she had
four times the legal limit of alcohol in her bloodstream. The medical
examiner also found traces of cocaine in her nostrils. She had been gang-raped
and severely beaten with a motorcycle chain, then dumped beneath a nearby
motorway overpass. The accomplices both testified against Elliott. When
Elliott began beating Joyce with the motorcycle chain, Hanson fled and called
his sister, who later called the police. The police found Joyce's body,
then arrested the trio. Elizondo pled guilty to sexual assault and received a 10
year sentence. Joyce’s family in Austin is watching the case closely. "My
sister's gone, but we're not,” said Lillian Munguia. “And what she can't fight
for, we're going to fight for.” Elliott wrote the Munguia family a letter on
Christmas Eve. "I have a mother and I see the pain in her eyes when she comes to
visit me and I know how much more pain there must have been for you over the
past years," Elliott said. But his written plea found no sympathy at the Munguia
home. “The letter means nothing,” Lillian Munguia said. “He's being selfish
again, talking about himself, how he sees the pain in his mother's eyes.” They
believe justice will be served by Elliott’s execution – an event they admit
they’re looking forward to watching.
In
1982, Elliott went to prison for killing a man in a
bar brawl. He was convicted again in 1984 of attempted burglary. But in an era
when Texas prisons were overcrowded because of a space shortage, he was released
under mandatory supervision after only 4 1/2 months of
his 8-year sentence for murder, then received probation for the burglary.
"If that happened today, what kind of firestorm would there have been in the
media?" Juan Gonzalez, an Austin homicide sergeant in 1986 who investigated the
slaying of Joyce Munguia, said Monday. "He had no business being out in society
again, at least not so soon. It's terribly frustrating to me. The
poor girl probably would still be alive if he had been in (prison) where
he should have been...If you think execution is not a deterrent, this is
a classic case. He was the main one, the ringleader," said
Gonzalez, now a patrol commander in the Austin police department. Police found
blood on his clothing matched Munguia's blood. His shoe prints were at the
murder scene. The 2 other men, who insisted they did not take part in the
slaying, pleaded guilty to rape charges. One received a 10-year prison term, the
other 15 years. "He was cool, collected and had no remorse," Gonzalez said,
recalling Elliott's arrest. "It didn't bother him. He knew what his rights were.
He didn't even say anything....He wasn't going to say much at all. He'd been
down the road before. He knew what to say and what not to say. "He didn't say:
'On no, I didn't do it.' He was just too cool." |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
February 5, 2003 |
Missouri |
Ronald Felts
|
Kenneth Kenley
|
executed |
|
The Missouri Supreme Court has set
a February 5th execution date for Kenneth Kenley, convicted of the January 1984
murder of Ronald Felts in Poplar Bluff during a two-day crime spree. On the
night of January 3, 1984, Kenley robbed a Poplar Bluff store after threatening
the sales clerk with a pistol. He abducted a female customer and tried to
sexually assault her in his vehicle but she escaped. Kenley entered
the former Blue Moon tavern, a Poplar Bluff bar
later that night and announced a holdup. Without warning, he shot patron Ronald
Felts in the head, killing him instantly.
Felts had been
playing pool with friends. The execution is scheduled for
12:01 a.m. Wednesday. Kenley, 42, has asked
Gov. Bob Holden and the U.S. Supreme Court to reduce his sentence to life in
prison. On Friday, the Missouri Supreme Court denied
Kenley's request for a new hearing. His lawyers filed another round of appeals
Monday with the U.S. District Court in St. Louis. Jackie and
Marty Felts were asleep when their 27-year-old son was murdered during the
robbery of a crowded tavern near Poplar Bluff, Mo., 19 years ago. Their
surviving son banged on their door at 3 a.m. to break the news. "It was the
hardest, most heart-wrenching thing I've ever had to do," said Sam Felts, now
44. "The whole thing tore up my parents. Dad died three years later, and we
think the heartache contributed. Mom kept a scrapbook on the case all these
years. She just wanted to know that the killer would be put to death." Jackie
Felts, 68, had made plans to drive up from Poplar Bluff to witness the
execution. But she died last week of a heart attack in her home. Since her
death, Sam Felts has decided against going. That leaves Ronnie Felts' widow, who
remarried, and their two grown children, who plan to stand outside a glass
window of the death chamber and watch Kenley die. Said Sam Felts: "We just hope
the governor doesn't pull a Ryan on us. For 19 years, it's all been about
Kenneth Kenley. It will be a relief when it's finally over." Mark Kennedy, the
former Butler County prosecutor who handled the case, said: "Mr. Kenley blames
his dad, but he himself was a mean guy. He got the pistol and practiced with it,
and he mapped out his plans pretty well. He tried to kill four people that
night. "We had 20 witnesses to the murder. When you look at what Mr. Kenley did,
and know that our society says the punishment should be death, then that's the
way it is. The only thing I'd like to know is whether he has made peace with
himself and his God." Kenley completed a four-year prison sentence for stealing
two months before his brief but violent crime rampage on Jan. 3-4, 1984. Ronnie
Felts finished his evening shift as a hospital X-ray technician and went to the
former Blue Moon tavern, five miles south of town. He was playing pool with
three friends when Kenley, then 23, burst through the front door shortly after
midnight and ordered everyone onto the floor. As most of the patrons stared at
him in shock, Kenley shouted, "I'll make an example of you," and fired his
.38-caliber pistol at Felts, striking him in the head. Kenley then shot and
wounded the bartender, and kidnapped the female owner of the Blue Moon. She
escaped in the parking lot. An hour earlier, Kenley had robbed a convenience
store in Poplar Bluff and kidnapped a customer. When he tried to force her to
have sex, she jumped from the car. Kenley shot her in the back, but she
survived. Shortly after killing Felts, Kenley tried to rob a motel, but his
pistol didn't fire when he aimed at the owner's husband. Kenley was arrested
later that morning in Corning, Ark., 30 miles south of Poplar Bluff, after
firing into a grocery store ceiling and demanding a getaway car. Kenley was
tried in Poplar Bluff and sentenced to death in June 1984. Seven years later,
the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in St. Louis ordered a new sentencing
hearing for Kenley, ruling that his defense lawyer hadn't put up an adequate
case after trial. In death penalty cases, juries determine guilt before hearing
a second round of arguments on whether the sentence should be death, or life in
prison. After a five-day resentencing hearing in Rolla, Mo., in 1994, Kenley was
condemned again. The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the case in October,
clearing the way for his execution. UPDATE: Kenneth Kenley, who murdered a pool
player to show he meant business while robbing a crowded tavern 19 years ago,
was executed by injection early today in the Potosi Correctional Center. Kenley
met Tuesday with relatives. Two cousins, an uncle and an in-law were prepared to
witness on his behalf. Phyllis Manns, who is Ronnie Felts' widow, and their
children, Mark Van Meter and Melissa Felts, all of Poplar Bluff, were scheduled
to witness from a nearby area for the victim's family. Regina Sanders, a
step-aunt to Kenley, spoke to him by telephone Tuesday. "He said, 'If they're
going to do it, they're going to do it,'" said Sanders, of Greenville, Texas. "I
asked him why he did (the murder). He said, "I had a death wish.'"
|
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
February 6, 2003 |
Texas |
Nicholas West, 23 |
Henry
Dunn |
executed |
|
Convicted killer Henry
Earl Dunn is scheduled to die for the 1993 murder of a
Tyler man. Judge Diane Devasto set the execution date for
February 6th. This is Dunn's 2nd execution date. Slated for
death last May, the execution was stayed. Dunn
admitted to taking part in the kidnapping of 23-year-old Nicholas
West of Tyler, who
was targeted because he was gay. On the evening of Nov. 30,
1993, Nicholas
was
kidnapped from a Montgomery Ward parking lot in Tyler,
driven to a clay pit, robbed and shot at least 9 times.
There were 2 other people charged with his
murder. Donald Aldrich, who is also on death row,
and David McMillan, who
was given a life sentence for aggravated
robbery and kidnapping. The murder was the culmination of a string of crimes
of escalating violence and severity perpetrated by the trio of Dunn, Aldrich,
and McMillan. The night Nicholas was abducted was bitterly cold. Dunn later
confessed that he, Aldrich and McMillan decided to find and assault homosexuals
at Bergfield Park in Tyler. Aldrich, McMillan and Dunn went to the park, which
was known as a local meeting place for homosexuals. Upon arrival, Aldrich
spotted a red Nissan truck that he recognized from a previous visit to the park.
Aldrich approached the red truck, occupied by
Nicholas, and posed as a homosexual in order to gain his
attention.
Nicholas invited Aldrich to join him and the two drove
together to a nearby Montgomery Ward parking lot. Dunn and McMillan followed in
another car. Once in the parking lot, Dunn, Aldrich and McMillan brandished
weapons and forced
Nicholas into the passenger seat of their car. While
Aldrich drove the red Nissan truck, Dunn held a gun on
Nicholas, and McMillan drove the car to a clay pit
approximately 10 miles outside of Tyler. Once they arrived, Dunn, Aldrich and
McMillan led
Nicholas at gunpoint away from the road and into the
clay pit. They began to push and taunt
Nicholas as they continued toward the clay pit. Before
marching him to the pit where he was murdered (which was located several hundred
yards from the road), he was stripped of his clothes, but not his underwear. He
had defecated in his underwear and the trio wanted to further humiliate him by
making him wear his dirty underwear. Nicholas was then pistol-whipped. Blinded
by the flow of blood from the gashes on his forehead and eyebrow, stripped of
his shoes and clothes, he was then forced in the bitter cold to embark on his
death march. If he fell, he was kicked, jeered, and taunted. When they reached
the clearing where the clay pit was located, Dunn fired his pistol into the air.
According to Dunn's videotaped confession, this act triggered a fusillade of
gunfire from Aldrich and McMillan, and
Nicholas was knocked face down into the mud. At the
pit, the shooting began - methodically, slowly, intentionally - apparently to
prolong his life and to prolong the suffering as long as possible. Dunn then
walked toward
Nicholas's body and fired at least four and as many as
six shots into
Nicholas. Dunn admitted that one of his shots probably
struck
Nicholas in the head. The first shots were to the
hand. Then there were shots to the arms. These were followed by superficial
shots to the torso. A shot to the abdomen, which the forensic expert testified
was not the killing shot, would have left Nicholas in terrific pain. And then
finally came the coup de grace, a shot to the back of the head.
Nicholas was shot as many as 15 times. As
Nicholas writhed on the ground and begged for the
shooting to stop, Aldrich, McMillan and Dunn ran back to the road where the
vehicles were parked. Aldrich drove
Nicholas's truck and McMillan and Dunn fled in the
car. Two days later, on December 2, a pair of dirt-bikers found Nicholas's
body lying face-down in the clay pit. A day after
the body was found, the authorities, acting on an informer's tip, arrested
29-year-old Donald Aldrich, 17-year-old David Ray McMillan and 19-year-old Henry
Dunn, Jr. for the murder of Nicholas West. Dunn was arrested in possession of
the red Nissan pickup. He gave a videotaped confession on December 3. Authorities in East Texas almost
immediately classified the murder as a hate crime, noting that evidence obtained
during suspect questioning made "it quite clear they targeted Mr. West because
he was a homosexual." In fact, Donald Aldrich, the reported leader of the group,
told authorities, "If you can walk into a 7-11 and rob a 7-11 for 15, 20 bucks,
get your face on videotape, have somebody that's gonna call the police; or if
you can go into a park, rob somebody that's out in the dark, come away with a
hell of a lot more - because of the fact that they're homosexual and they don't
want people to know it, they're not gonna go report it to the police. Who you
gonna go rob? Where you're gonna get in the least amount of trouble." At
trial, evidence showed that Dunn previously had assaulted a girl as they both
exited a school bus. Dunn choked her and repeatedly struck her in the throat
before the bus driver stopped the attack. Dunn then smashed the windows out of
the bus door and attempted to follow the girl back onto the bus before the
driver subdued him.
|
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
February 12, 2003 |
Ohio |
Leslie Renae Keckler, 18 |
Richard Fox
|
executed |
|
The
Wood county prosecuting attorney indicates that Richard Fox's execution date is
set for February 12, 2003. According to the Wood county prosecuting attorney,
Fox has exhausted all of his appeals. He will be executed unless governor Taft
of a court intervenes. Fox was convicted in the 1990 kidnapping and murder of
18-year-old Leslie Keckler, a student at Bowling Green State University. Fox is
scheduled to be executed Feb. 12 for the 1989 murder of a college student he had
lured to a nonexistent job interview. When the victim, Leslie Keckler, rejected
Fox's sexual advances and tried to get out of the car, Fox stabbed and strangled
her, prosecutors said.
Police were led to Fox when they remembered a similar incident involving a
Bowling Green State University student who had escaped from a man who had lured
her into his car under a similar pretext.
The key evidence against
Fox included bloodstains in his car and a knife, which prosecutors said was used
to kill Leslie. In 1994 the U.S. Supreme court refused to hear the case.
Attorneys for Fox argued Wood county prosecutors shouldn't have released a
confession Fox gave to police shortly after his arrest. Prosecutor Alan Mayberry
says frustration over the death penalty appeals process in cases such as Fox's,
is what prompted Ohio voters to pass a state issue that sets a constitutional
amendment on the number of appeals filed by the condemned. A 3 judge panel had
sentenced Fox to die in the electric chair. Since that is no longer used, Fox
will be executed by lethal injection. UPDATE:
Convicted murderer Richard E. Fox should
find no mercy from Gov. Bob Taft, the Ohio Parole Board said.
The board unanimously recommended that the governor reject Fox’s petition
for clemency, allowing his execution to proceed as planned on Feb. 12. Fox was
convicted in the Sept. 26, 1989, murder and kidnapping of Leslie Renae Keckler,
an 18-year-old Owens Technical College freshman lured to a fraudulent job
interview. "Only now at the midnight hour has Fox had
any type of remorse and found God," said new Wood County Prosecutor Raymond
Fischer. "He has had eight or nine different stories of what happened. Even a
couple of parole board members said he was still glib in his statements to them
just two weeks ago." "His story has changed
eight times since he first claimed an alibi," said Kim Norris, spokesman for
Attorney General Jim Petro. "He’s still blaming the
victim, saying she didn’t realize it was a date when he stalked her and got her
information off a job application," spokesman Norris added. "Clearly they were
not," she said. "These women were duped into getting into a vehicle with him.
They were not dates. His apologies continue to ring
hollow." Jeff Sutton, one of Fox’s attorneys
said, "It was fraud to be sure, but it was not designed to commit sexual
assault, certainly not to commit murder." The daughter
of Fox asked the Ohio Parole Board to recommend that Gov. Bob Taft spare the
life of the man taken from her by police 13 years ago.
"In killing him, you are doing exactly what he did - taking another life," said
Jessica Fox, who was 6 at the time her father was arrested.
"He has asked for forgiveness for what he has done," she said. "He is a
changed man who would not even think about doing anything he has done in the
past." However, the family of Leslie Renae Keckler,
said the death-row inmate can expect no forgiveness from them. They asked the
state to restore the victim’s dignity by carrying out Fox’s execution as
scheduled on Feb. 12. Ms. Keckler’s family
told the board Fox’s apologies are insincere and that he continues to
partially blame her for what happened that night.
"From the first time Fox saw Leslie, he thought of her as something less than a
human being created by God," said her younger brother, Chad. "He thought of her
as a toy, a toy that he could play with and manipulate to amuse him, and when
his toy no longer pleased him, he destroyed her, then threw her away."Gov.
Bob Taft rejected Richard E. Fox’s plea for mercy one week before the state is
scheduled to put him to death for killing an 18-year-old college student 13
years ago. "There is no doubt that Mr. Fox is guilty of brutally murdering
Leslie Keckler," said Mr. Taft. "The claims of error with respect to the
imposition of the death sentence advanced by attorneys for Mr. Fox have been
reviewed and rejected by state and federal courts. There are no discussions in
this case that would indicate any manifest injustice," he said. "I find that the
aggravating circumstances and brutality of Mr. Fox’s crime outweigh any
mitigating factors he has presented. I can find no compelling reason to grant
clemency." Fox, a Tontogany native, is scheduled to be executed at 10 a.m.
Wednesday at the Southern Ohio Correctional Institution near Lucasville. He
would be the sixth man executed since Ohio resumed carrying out the death
penalty in 1999 and the first from northwest Ohio. He was convicted of
aggravated murder and kidnapping for luring Leslie, a freshman at Owens
Technical College, to an interview in Bowling Green on Sept. 26, 1989, for a
nonexistent restaurant-supply sales job. He convinced her to get into his car
under the pretext of showing her the sales route and drove to a rural area north
of the city. When she rejected his advances, he stabbed her six times and
strangled her. Fox’s attorneys have argued that the murder was out of character
for Fox, that he had no criminal record prior to the killing, and has been a
model prisoner while on death row. The state, however, presented Fox as a
predator who started out sexually harassing young job applicants and progressed
to fabricating job interviews to get women alone to fulfill a long-held rape
fantasy. "The Ohio Adult Parole Board gave a complete review of the matter and
rendered an 8-0 unanimous decision to recommend denying clemency to Fox," said
Wood County Prosecutor Raymond Fischer. "Governor Taft indicated that he spent
considerable time reviewing the entire record in Mr. Fox’s case. We believe that
due process has been afforded to Mr. Fox and to the family of Leslie Keckler,"
Mr. Fischer said. Leslie’s father, Lester, and two brothers, Chad and Brad, are
expected to witness the execution. Fox’s daughter, Jessica, 6 years old when her
father was imprisoned 13 years ago, also plans to be there. |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
February 13, 2003 |
Oklahoma |
Louise Schem,
77 |
Bobby
Fields |
executed |
|
Bobby
Joe Fields pleaded guilty in 1994 to the 1983 murder of 77-year-old Louise Schem
in Oklahoma County. Fields was burglarizing Schem's home for money to support
his drug habit when she confronted him, prosecutors say. Fields shot her to
death. On March 1, 1993, Shirley Masterson, Bobby Joe Fields's girlfriend,
invited Fields to party at her duplex. Masterson's Aid to Families with
Dependent Children check had arrived and she planned on using the money to buy
alcohol and cocaine. Shawanda and Yolanda Pittman, Masterson's grown daughters,
and Dia Russell, Shawanda and Yolanda's friend, were partying with Masterson and
Fields. The party continued the next day, March 2, 1993. Sometime around noon,
Fields walked two doors down to Louise Schem's house ostensibly to ask if he
could do yard work for her. She declined. In the mid- to late-afternoon, Fields
went to the upstairs-half of Masterson's duplex to ask Albert Anuario if he
wanted to buy a television and VCR for $70. Anuario, who had also been drinking,
replied that he was interested but that he did not have enough money. Fields
decided to steal Schem's television and sell it to buy more cocaine. When,
around 5 p.m., he again walked down the block to carry out the robbery, he
thought Schem was not at home. He opened the screen door, pushed open the front
door, crossed the living room to the television (which was on), and reached to
unplug it. At that moment, Schem entered the room carrying her .25
semi-automatic pistol. A struggle ensued as the two of them wrestled to control
the gun. Despite the fact that, at the time, Fields was thirty years-old, 5' 7"
tall, and weighed 140 pounds while Schem was elderly, 5' 4" tall, and 114
pounds, their struggle was protracted: it began in the living room, spilled out
the front door and down the steps, and ended on the sidewalk in front of Schem's
house. Robert Vallejo happened to be driving by and saw the final seconds of the
altercation. He testified that he saw them struggling on the sidewalk, heard
Schem cry "Help! Help!", heard a gunshot, and watched Schem fall to the
sidewalk. The government's medical examiner testified that the bullet had a flat
trajectory it entered the back, left-side of Schem's neck, beneath her left
ear, passed through her spinal cord and the back of her mouth, and exited her
mouth, fracturing two of her incisor teeth. The gunpowder residue on the back of
her neck indicated that the shot was fired from six to twelve inches. Vallejo
drove away a short distance, made a U-turn, and returned to the scene. Fields
had fled, but he returned to Masterson's house thirty to forty minutes later. As
he walked in Masterson's back door, the pistol went off. Dia Russell testified
that Fields looked hysterical he was talking fast and breathing heavily.
Perhaps half an hour after returning to Masterson's house, he went upstairs and
sold the gun to Anuario for $40. Shortly after the police and medical personnel
started arriving at Schem's house, Russell took Masterson and Fields to Fields's
sister's house. Russell testified that during the drive Fields said that "he
didn't have any kind of remorse or guilt" and "he wouldn't lose any sleep"
because "white people deserve what they got." (Fields is black; Schem was
white.) In addition, she testified that later, while they were watching a news
story of how the police had arrested a different black man for the murder, he
said that he was "relieved" that he might not get caught and that "he had
thought about being on the television show America's Most Wanted." Two
days after the murder, on March 4, 1993, Fields was arrested and interrogated.
He told the police that, thinking Schem was not home, he went to her house to
steal her television. When she surprised him with a gun, he jumped at her in
self-defense, and they wrestled over the weapon. The struggle spilled out onto
the sidewalk, where he pulled the gun from her hands. As he did so, it went off
accidentally, killing her. |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
February 18, 2003 |
Texas |
James Benton
Atkinson, Jr., 45 |
Gregory Van Alstyne |
stayed |
|
Gregory Van
Alstyne was convicted of the April 17, 1990 robbery and murder of 45-year-old
James Benton Atkinson, Jr. James was a delivery man for a Pizza Hut
restaurant in Amarillo. James had been dispatched to deliver a pizza order
and never returned. Van Alstyne later confessed that he and co-defendant
Ricky Dale Allen stabbed and beat James to death when he arrived at the
residence with the pizza. They robbed him of the money he was carrying,
less than $20. The killers then drove the victim's vehicle to a remote
area and dumped his body. Van Alstyne was arrested after he bragged about
the murder. Van Alstyne had a prior conviction for robbery, for which he
had served less than one year of a five year sentence. He was released on
parole seven days before murdering James. Allen received a life sentence
for the murder. UPDATE: A Texas death row inmate scheduled to die next week won
a reprieve from the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. Gregory Van Alstyne, 37,
was condemned for the April 1990 robbery and fatal stabbing and beating of James
Atkinson Jr., a pizza delivery man in Amarillo. The appeals court halted the
lethal injection set for next Tuesday and returned the case to the trial court
in Potter County for review. At the time of the April 17, 1990, slaying, Van
Alstyne had been on parole seven days after serving about 11 months of a
five-year term for robbery. Atkinson, 45, was robbed of $16. Van Alstyne claims
another man killed him. |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
February 25, 2003 |
Texas |
Jeanette Williams,
48 |
Richard Williams |
executed |
|
Richard
Williams was convicted of the contract murder of 48-year-old Jeanette Williams,
who was in a wheelchair and is no relation. For $400, Richard Williams cut her
throat and stabbed her repeatedly with an 8-inch steak knife and left her body
in the middle of a southeast Houston street on March 24, 1997. The married
couple who arranged the killing, Bruce and Michelle Gilmore, received life
sentences. Williams, 33, is seeking to have his execution delayed on the grounds
that he may be mentally retarded, a defense made possible last year when the
U.S. Supreme Court ruled that executing the mentally retarded is cruel and
unusual punishment. A victims advocate called mental retardation the "brass
ring" for death row defendants. At least seven Texas death row inmates have had
their executions postponed on the grounds that they may be mentally retarded.
The latest was Gregory Van Alstyne, who was scheduled to be executed last
Tuesday. Several more appeals on the grounds of mental retardation are pending.
The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has not yet ruled on Williams' claim. "I'm
trying to get off death row," Williams said. "I've got a life to live." A Harris
County jury in 1997 convicted Williams of murdering 44-year-old Jeanette
Williams, no relation. Richard Williams turned himself in after his brothers
told him police were looking for him. He confessed to the contract killing, then
pleaded not guilty at trial. In the confession, Williams said Bruce and Michelle
Gilmore offered him $12,000 to kill Jeanette Williams, their friend. They wanted
to collect on the $25,000 life insurance policy they had taken out on the woman.
The Gilmores are serving life sentences for their role in the crime. A crack
addict who had been paralyzed for two decades, Jeanette Williams had lived with
the Gilmores on and off for about six years, even moving with them among
Houston, Oklahoma and South Carolina. Richard Williams had been out of prison
for less than a month when he met the trio. He had served 10 years for a crime
spree that included two burglaries, arson and aggravated sexual assault, all
committed when he was 17 years old. Williams was staying with his friend Jerrol
Blueford when the Gilmores and Jeanette Williams came over for a visit,
according to trial testimony. Bruce Gilmore took Richard Williams outside to
solicit his help in the murder. Williams confessed to police that he agreed to
the crime then. The three co-defendants hashed out the details and price over
several subsequent conversations during a couple of drug-filled days, according
to the confession and trial testimony. Jeanette Williams often sat in the next
room as the other three discussed her murder. Williams said he and the victim
even slept in the same bed one night. After his arrest, Williams calmly told
police that he talked the Gilmores out of two of their plans for killing
Jeanette Williams, including shooting her -- he said the gun would be too loud
-- and taking her out of state for the murder. He worried they would be more
readily connected with her if they traveled. "I said, `Look, Michelle, let me do
my work. Have my money for me and that will be the end of it,' " Williams told
police afterward. " `Once I take care of my business, if y'all ain't got my
money, then it might be one of y'all being dead, because I don't play about my
money.' " He said last week that he was "high and drunk" when he went to the
police. Williams opted for killing the victim with a 9-inch steak knife supplied
by the Gilmores. The four went on a crack-buying expedition in central Houston
on March 24, 1997. Michelle Gilmore wheeled Jeanette Williams down the street in
her wheelchair. Richard Williams grabbed the victim's forehead from behind, slit
her throat and, after she fell from her wheelchair, stabbed her 13 times. During
the killing, the Gilmores drove to Blueford's house. They told him that
Williams was crazy, and that Williams had murdered Jeanette. They left $400 and
told him not to tell Williams where they had gone. Williams walked back to
Blueford's house and learned the Gilmores had cheated him out of most of the
payment. "When they come back in Texas, I'm going to bury them," he told police.
During his trial, Williams' attorneys raised the issue of his intelligence,
calling several witnesses who said he should undergo neurological testing. But
when the prosecutor asked Dee Dee Halpin, an educational diagnostician
testifying for the defense, if Williams was mentally retarded, she said, "No."
She testified that he scored a 93 on an IQ test when was 6. A bill before the
Texas Legislature, which is trying to make the state's death penalty law agree
with last year's Supreme Court decision, would classify defendants with an IQ of
70 or below as mentally retarded. Williams said last week he believes he is
mentally retarded. His attorney, James Keegan, did not return calls seeking
comment. Prosecutor Lynn Hardaway, who is handling Williams' appeal, disputed
the claim, saying Williams has average to low-average intelligence. Noting the
number of condemned men who have claimed mental retardation since the Supreme
Court began considering the issue, Dianne Clements, president of the victims
advocacy group Justice For All, said it has become a "brass ring" for those on
death row. "He and his attorney will grab at whatever straw is available," she
said. But Jim Marcus, executive director of Texas Defender Service, said the
issue of whether Williams is mentally retarded needs to be examined and that the
answer could shift more culpability to his co-defendants. "One of the traits of
mentally retarded people is that they're very easily led ... or persuaded by
others," Marcus said. "It could be that he's an extremely limited and vulnerable
individual." But Williams acts tough, boasting that his gang might kill Blueford
for testifying against him. "I am a gang member and a gang leader," he said,
adding that he was in the West Side Crips and his street name is Panama. "This
dude is in fear (for) his life every day." Later in the interview, Williams said
he told the Crips not to kill Blueford so he would not be blamed for Blueford's
death. "He might turn up dead in a few years," Williams said, "but I won't have
anything to do with it." UPDATE: Richard Head Williams was contrite and took
responsibility for his crimes in a final statement seconds before the lethal
drugs began flowing into his arms. "I'd like to apologize for all the pain I've
caused," he said. Looking at 3 brothers of his victim, "I'm sorry I caused what
happened to your sister. I apologize." He expressed love to his family and while
acknowledging he made mistakes said, "I was not a monster like they claimed I
was. I made a mistake and this mistake cost - but they won't cost no more."
However, in an interview earlier this month, Williams said he never saw or knew
the victim, Jeanette Williams, 44, and that his criminal past earned him the
trip to death row. "The way I look at it, the whole trial was rehearsed," he
said then. "They used everything I did in my life against me. It had nothing to
do with my case, but that's the way the system is designed, to get railroaded.
I'm just a dumb black man with no money, caught in the system." Vanessa
Velasquez, the Harris County district attorney who prosecuted Williams asked,
"Then why did he give that confession? I had hoped he would reconcile with his
own guilt. That's unfortunate. I think he was a cold-blooded killer. He slit a
woman's throat who couldn't walk, was a paraplegic, from ear to ear, on a dark
street," Velasquez said. "She fell out of the chair but that wasn't enough. He
had to continue stabbing her. She was found laying in the road like a wounded
dead animal, with her wheelchair thrown to the side." Williams contended, "I
ain't did nothing to nobody," insisting he was in Louisiana at the time of the
slaying, never received any money for the killing and "didn't know no Gilmores.
The whole thing is a setup," he said, also blaming his earlier incarcerations
for "being at the wrong place at the wrong time. There were cases I had nothing
to do with, but I'm not a snitch," he said. "I wasn't going to rat on anyone."
While in prison with a 10-year term for sexual assault, burglary and arson,
records showed he had more than 100 disciplinary violations, including assaults
and threats on corrections officers. He was discharged Feb. 28, 1997. Jeanette
Williams was killed 24 days later. |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
February 26, 2003 |
Texas |
Jeff Wetterman, 27 |
Michael Johnson
|
stayed |
|
On
May 8, 1996, Michael Dewayne Johnson was sentenced to death for the capital
murder of Jeff Wetterman, which occurred in Lorena, Texas, on Sept. 10, 1995.
Around Sept. 9, 1995, David Vest went to Michael Johnson's house. While at the
house, Vest saw a 9 mm gun sitting on a table. After Vest returned home, some
friends came by in a stolen Cadillac. Vest drove the Cadillac for a while,
letting off each passenger in turn until only he was left in the vehicle. Vest
next began heading for his home when he pulled into a parking lot and noticed
Johnson talking on a public telephone. Vest motioned for Johnson to get into the
car, and the two drove around for a while. They subsequently went back to
Johnson's house, and Johnson briefly went inside. Johnson returned to the stolen
Cadillac with the 9 mm gun tucked in his waistband. After one more stop, Vest
and Johnson headed to the coast. Around Waco, Vest and Johnson were getting low
on gas and decided to "make a gas run." "Making a gas run" was another way of
saying they were going to steal some gas by stopping, jumping out and pumping
the gas, and then taking off. After switching positions so that Johnson was
driving, they approached two different stations, but decided the circumstances
were unfavorable at both. Around 7:00 a.m. on September 10, they drove to a
convenience store/gas station and Vest jumped out and started pumping gasoline.
As he was doing so, Jeff Wetterman, who had been married just three weeks
earlier, came outside and began talking to Vest. It was the policy of the store
to provide full-service to all gasoline customers. Johnson then got out of the
car and walked to the rear of the vehicle. Vest asked Johnson whether he had the
gun on him and Johnson lifted his shirt to reveal the weapon. As Vest returned
the gas nozzle to the pump after filling the tank with $24 worth of gas, he
heard a shot and saw Wetterman fall. Jeff was shot in the face, the bullet
severing his spinal cord. Vest and Johnson got back into the car and sped away.
Johnson and Vest then drove to Corpus Christi and on home to Dallas. Along the
way, Johnson sold the gun to a truck driver for $35 for gas, drinks and
cigarettes. The day following the murder, Vest saw an account of the murder on
TV and told his mother what had happened. They were both arrested in Dallas
three days after the murder. Officers who arrived on the scene after the murder,
talked to Wetterman's co-worker, Lois Bean, who testified that Wetterman had
gone to the pumps to tend to a customer when Bean heard a noise that sounded
like a shot. When she looked toward the pumps, she saw Wetterman sitting on the
ground and saw a blond-haired man standing by the passenger door of what she
later identified to be a Cadillac. Bean then saw the man get in the passenger
side of the vehicle and the two drove off. After the crime, Johnson was with a
friend at Vest's house when Johnson told the friend that they had pulled into a
station to get gas when an attendant came out. Johnson said that he shot
Wetterman in the face after he thought Vest had said "shoot." Although Johnson
argued at trial that he had an alibi and was at home at the time of the offense,
he admitted to a psychologist who examined him after he was convicted that he
was in fact at the gas station when the murder occurred. |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
February 26, 2003 |
Florida |
Natalie "Tillie" Brady, 68 |
Amos King |
executed |
|
Amos
King, was sentenced to be executed for the murder of Natalie "Tillie" Brady, 68,
who was raped, stabbed and beaten in her Tarpon Springs home in 1977. Natalie
Brady, known to many as "Tillie", came from an old Tarpon Springs family. She
was described as a well-liked Christian woman, a widow who lived alone in a
one-story house at the end of Brady Road. In March of 1977, Amos King was an
inmate at Tarpon Springs Community Correctional Center, a minimum security
work-release facility, where he was serving a sentence for larceny of a firearm.
On March 17 he worked at a Clearwater restaurant from 5:00 p.m. until 1:00 a.m.
the following morning. An inmate van picked him up at around 1:30 a.m., and he
checked back into the facility at approximately 2:35 a.m. At about 3:40 a.m.,
the prison counselor, James McDonough, discovered King missing during a routine
bed check. McDonough found King outside the building with blood on his pants.
After McDonough escorted King back into the facility, a fight broke out between
the two in which King repeatedly stabbed McDonough with a knife. King then fled
the facility. Police rushing to help McDonough, who was found to have been
stabbed more than 25 times, spotted a blaze at Brady's home. Firefighters found
her body in a doorway where she had crawled to escape the flames. She had been
raped, stabbed and beaten. King admits he almost killed work release guard James
"Dan" McDonough, who lived to tell of discovering King trying to sneak back into
the center about the time Brady was killed. But King denies killing Brady and
alleges evidence was planted to convict a black man for the murder of an elderly
white woman. She had received two stab wounds,
bruises over the chin, and burns on the leg. An autopsy revealed other injuries,
which included bruises on the back of the head, hemorrhaging of the brain,
hemorrhaging of the neck, and broken cartilage in the neck. There was a ragged
tear of the vagina which apparently had been caused by blood-stained wooden
knitting needles found at the scene. There was also evidence of forced sexual
intercourse. Arson investigators concluded the fire had been set intentionally
sometime between 3:00 and 3:30 a.m. Tillie's home was just 1,500 feet away from
the work release facility. The government presented strong circumstantial
evidence of King's guilt on the murder charge. Joan Wood, the medical examiner
who performed an autopsy on the deceased, for example, testified that King's
blood type was present in the victim's vaginal washings. Woods stated that if
Tillie's assailant had raped her with his pants on after causing the tear to the
wall of her vagina, blood would have been present on the clothing, as McDonough
had found on the crotch area of King's pants. She testified the paring knife
used by King to assault McDonough was "consistent" with the wounds found on
Tillie, but she admitted she could not say this knife caused the wound. A knife
salesman testified that the paring knife was manufactured by the same company
and was similar in design to other kitchen knives found in Tillie's house. An
old friend of the deceased testified that the paring knife resembled one Tillie
kept in her house. The relatives of Tillie Brady say they would rather not hear
King's name ever again. Eva Lysek, one of Tillie's sisters, doesn't care whether
King lives or dies. "I just do not want them to let him out," said Ms. Lysek,
who lives in Pinellas County and still regularly puts flowers on her sister's
grave on holidays. "All I can say is, I do not have a sister. I have not had a
sister for 25 years." King had been scheduled for execution in January, July and
December in 2002, but received a stay both times. At the time of the January
stay, a victim's advocate said the family was disappointed and discouraged.
"Their opinion is it's just a joke now," said Wendy Hallowell, who spoke with
Tillie's niece. King had previous execution dates in 1981 and 1988. When Marie
Williams heard that the death warrant for her sister's killer had been
reactivated in June of 2002, she knew what was coming: a new round of
frustrations. "It's just bringing back old memories all the time. It's been 25
years," said Mrs. Williams, who lives in St. Petersburg. "It's just another one
of those things that he'll get another appeal. That's what happened the last
three times." "It's about time," said Abe Tarapani, summing up the feeling of
many Tarpon Springs residents who are outraged at the delay. Despite the passage
of time, for many family and friends of Mrs. Brady, the pain is still fresh, the
venom still strong. "This man needs to burn to a crisp for what he did to her,"
said former Tarpon Springs Mayor Anita Protos. "It's been too long in coming. He
should not have been shown any mercy to last this long." Blaine LeCouris, who
was the Tarpon Springs police chief in 1977, said the murder made for a very
trying chapter in Tarpon Springs history. LeCouris, a proponent of the work
release program, said many residents opposed the location of the minimum
security corrections facility, where inmates work during the day outside the
facility and return at night. "We need these facilities, but no one wants them
near them," LeCouris said. "In counties as close as Pinellas County, there's
nowhere you can put them where they aren't around someone." Tillie's murder
reignited the debate. LeCouris, father of current police chief Mark LeCouris,
said that Mrs. Brady was well-known in the Tarpon community. "She was a good
friend of mine," LeCouris said. "She was like a mother to a bunch of us. A
better woman never lived. She was just a kind woman." Tempers ran high after
King's arrest, he said. "We almost would've killed him ourselves if we could've
got ahold of him," LeCouris said. "He took the life of a sweet, innocent lady."
Elizabeth Palmer of Tarpon Springs, a friend of Tillie's, said the length of the
appeals angers her. "This was a cut-and-dry case," Palmer said. "This should
have been done two days after they caught him. It's hideous what he did to that
lady. And (the execution) is way past due. It doesn't seem fair sometimes. I
will never understand it." The scars in Tarpon Springs may never heal, she said.
"It was an absolute shock that something like this could happen," Palmer said.
"I go back to the day before this happened and think how peaceful it was,"
LeCouris said. "Here was a hardworking woman who lived alone, and he killed
her." *UPDATE - 12/02: Amos King, who escaped 2 other dates with death this
year, escaped a 3rd time Monday when Gov. Jeb Bush granted a 30-day stay so DNA
tests can be run. King was due to be executed at 6 p.m. by lethal injection when
he won the stay after lawyer Barry Scheck of the Innocence Project met with the
governor's death penalty attorney earlier Monday. King, 48, was condemned for
raping and murdering Natalie Brady, 68, in her Tarpon Springs home in 1977 and
setting the place ablaze after slipping away from a work-release prison. He was
caught, in bloody clothing, trying to slip back in. Bush issued the stay due to
new DNA techniques that were not available at the time of King's conviction in
1977. In a statement, Bush said Scheck "informed my legal office of the
existence of previously untested evidence and further DNA testing that could
possibly exonerate Amos King. It is wholly appropriate that we delay the
execution until we can determine that all potentially useful DNA testing has
been completed,"
Bush said. Scheck said he was "gratified and very pleased" - but not surprised
after his meeting with Wendy Berger, the governor's death penalty lawyer. "I had
confidence that Gov. Bush would do this," Scheck said, adding that the test
results are "just the kind of thing you don't want to leave any chance to."
King's lawyers called The Innocence Project for help about 10 days ago. They
want to test 3 pubic hairs and scrapings from under Brady's fingernails. The
execution was rescheduled for Jan 8. King had spent his final day with his
religious adviser, Casey Walpole, a Gainesville Buddhist. King's jury had voted
unanimously to recommend that he receive the death penalty. An autopsy
determined that his victim had two stab wounds, bruises on the
back of her head, bleeding of the brain and neck, a broken cartilage in her neck
and a tear in her vagina. King had received stays of execution in February and
July from the U.S. and Florida supreme courts. They had debated whether
Florida's death penalty law is similar to Arizona's, which was declared
unconstitutional by the nation's high court. UPDATE:
A third round of DNA tests failed to provide any proof of innocence or guilt for
death row inmate Amos King, scheduled to die later this month for the 1977
killing of a Tarpon Springs woman. A judge allowed a third series of tests on
the nightgown Natalie Brady wore when she was raped and murdered in her home. A
pair of wooden knitting needles presumably used in the attack were also tested.
King has maintained his innocence, but with the newest test results not proving
it, he remains scheduled to be executed Feb. 26. Earlier testing by the Florida
Department of Law Enforcement on the nightgown and needles turned up no
biological material from an attacker and earlier tests also proved inconclusive.
"They haven't found anything in 26 years,'' said Brady's niece, Monica Watson.
"They'll never find anything.'' Monica planned to attend the execution but
had prepared for disappointment after enduring years of delays and stays. "Why
did she have to die and somebody who was never productive got to live all these
years?" she said. "This is hanging over our heads. You hate to be wishing
someone is going to die. It's just that finally, someone is going to be held
accountable." Watson said she is tired of hearing how King might be an innocent
man. She said the family is unhappy that King has Web sites devoted to his cause
that make scant mention of how her aunt was brutalized in her final moments.
"She was one of those people you just wanted to be like," Watson said. "If it is
over tomorrow, we will just feel like she can rest in peace. ... I just hope
that he can ask for forgiveness and go quietly." |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
February 28, 2003 |
North Carolina |
Herman Smith Jr. |
Ernest Hartman |
stayed |
|
A
judge stopped the pending execution of a convicted murderer while the state
Supreme Court considers another case raising the same legal issue. Northampton
County Superior Court Judge Cy Grant issued the execution stay for Edward Ernest
Hartman, 38, who was scheduled to be put to death by lethal injection at Central
Prison in Raleigh on Feb. 28. Hartman's attorneys had raised an issue being
considered in the case of fellow death-row inmate Henry Lee Hunt: whether murder
indictments must include the "aggravating circumstances" that elevate 1st-degree
murder to a capital offense, making the killer eligible for the death penalty.
Hunt's attorneys will argue the issue at the state Supreme Court in April. The
outcome could affect all 202 inmates on North Carolina's death row, none of
whose indictments included aggravators, according to the state Attorney
General's Office. The Attorney General's Office will not appeal Hartman's stay,
spokesman John Bason said. Hartman's guilt is not in question. He confessed to
the June 1993 killing and robbery of Herman Smith Jr., for which he was
convicted of 1st-degree murder and sentenced to death in 1994. He also was
sentenced to 40 years in prison for armed robbery. Hartman told authorities he
drank 16 cans of beer before firing a pistol at close range into Smith's head
while Smith watched television in a recliner chair in the home they shared.
Hartman told a friend that the elderly Smith was wealthy and carried thousands
of dollars in his pocket, according to court records. Hartman took Smith's car
and left his body in the chair. Five days later, after taking several trips in
the car, Hartman said he was bothered by the smell of decay and dragged Smith's
body to a stable and buried it. Hartman's trial lawyers presented evidence that
he had psychiatric problems including depression, anxiety, and a history of
alcohol abuse. |
Page visited
times since 12/26/02
Page last updated
10/05/08 |